As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
When choosing between an infant car seat vs all in one , it’s easy to feel torn. Infant car seats are designed specifically for newborns, offering a snug and secure fit for early months.
Different from other car seats, all-in-one seats change with your child, going from rear-facing to forward-facing and then to a booster seat.
They are popular for long-term use because they are flexible but bigger and harder to move around than baby seats. To make an informed choice, you need to know the differences between these two types of car seats.
Whether you’re a first-time parent or a seasoned caregiver, this guide will help you navigate the pros and cons of each option to ensure your child’s safety on the road.
To help you make the best decision, we’ve compared these car seat types across critical factors like safety, convenience, cost, and longevity.
What Is an Infant Car Seat?
Infant car seats are rear-facing car seats designed for newborns and infants. They often come equipped with click-and-go bases, allowing easy transfer between your car and a compatible stroller. Most infant car seats accommodate babies up to 30-35 lbs or around 12 months old (depending on the model).
Best For: Newborns and families that prioritize portability.
Pros:
- Perfect Fit for Newborns: Infant seats accommodate little newborns snugly for safety and comfort.
- Portability: The click-and-go functionality makes moving your baby easily without waking them.
- Lightweight: Infant seats weigh less than convertibles, making them easier to carry.
- Compatibility with Strollers: Many infant car seats attach to strollers, doubling as a travel system.
Cons:
- Limited Longevity: Once your baby outgrows the weight/height limit, you’ll need to purchase another seat.
- Additional Cost: You’ll eventually need to invest in a convertible car seat, which increases overall spending.
It is ideal for families who are frequently on the go or need maximum convenience when traveling with an infant.
What Is an All-in-One Car Seat?
All-in-one car seats are designed to grow with your child, converting from a rear-facing seat for infants to a forward-facing seat and eventually to a belt-positioning booster. They provide long-term car seats for youngsters 5 to 120 pounds.
Best For: Families looking for an affordable, one-time investment.
Pros:
- Versatile: Covers all stages (infant to booster), eliminating the need to buy multiple seats.
- Cost-Effective: Saves money in the long run compared to purchasing different car seats for each stage.
- High Weight Limits: Many versions fit taller, older children and offer longer rear-facing alternatives for safety.
Cons:
- Bulkier Size: All-in-one seats tend to be heavier and more challenging to move between vehicles.
- Fit for Newborns: Some models may not provide an ideal fit for very small infants, even with inserts.
- No Click-and-Go: These seats are not portable and must stay in the car at all times.
Great for families who want a long-term, no-fuss car seat but might not prioritize portability.
Key Differences Between Infant Car Seat vs All in One
Infant Car Seat Feature
- Suitability: Newborns and infants (up to ~12 months)
- Longevity: Short-term (~1 year)
- Portability: Highly portable with a lightweight design
- Cost: Lower initial cost, but needs upgrading
- Ease of Use: Easy to transfer between car and stroller
- Space Requirement: Compact, fits in smaller cars
- Best For: On-the-go parents, travel systems
All-in-One Car Seat Feature
- Suitability: Newborns through childhood
- Longevity: Long-term (up to ~10 years)
- Portability: Not portable; stays in the ca
- Cost: Higher upfront cost but long-lasting
- Ease of Use: Fixed installation
- Space Requirement: Bulkier, takes up more space
Best For: Cost-conscious families, heavy use
Infant Car Seat vs All in One Car Seat Comparison In 2025
| Image | Product | Detail | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
 | Graco SnugRide 35 Lite LX Infant Car Seat |
| Price |
 | Evenflo LiteMax 35 Infant Car Seat |
| Price |
 | Evenflo Pivot Modular Travel System Infant Car Seat |
| Price |
 | Safety 1st Grow and Go All-in-One |
| Price |
 | Safety 1st Crosstown DLX All-in-One |
| Price |
Graco SnugRide 35 Lite LX Infant Car Seat
- Lightweight & Portable: It weighs only 7.2 lbs, making it easy to carry your baby from car to stroller.
- Protection First: Graco Protect Plus is engineered and designed to pass the most rigorous crash tests for ultimate safety.
- Custom Fit: 4-position adjustable base with easy-to-read level indicator ensures perfect installation every time.
- Ultimate Comfort: Soft knit head and body supports provide a cozy, snug fit for babies as small as 4 lbs.
- Easy to Install: For added convenience, it can be installed with either a vehicle seat belt or a LATCH system.
- Versatile Travel System: Attaches seamlessly to Graco strollers for effortless on-the-go use.
- Enhanced Shade: Multi-position canopy shields your baby from the sun, keeping them comfortable on all journeys
Evenflo LiteMax 35 Infant Car Seat
- Super Lightweight Design: It weighs only 8.17 lbs, making it incredibly easy to carry a baby from car to stroller.
- Good to Grow: It supports infants from 4 to 35 lbs and adapts with 4 adjustable harness positions as your baby grows.
- Comfortable Ergonomic Handle: Carrying is made easy with an ergonomic handle designed for maximum comfort.
- Full Coverage Canopy: Shields your baby from sun, wind, and rain for added protection during outings.
- Simple, Secure Installation: Features a vehicle belt lock-off system for quick, secure installation with LATCH or seat belt.
- Stay-In-Car Base: Includes a base with a recline indicator for proper installation and easy transitions between vehicles.
- Safety Tested: Exceeds federal safety standards, including rollover and temperature tests, for peace of mind.
Evenflo Pivot Modular Travel System Infant Car Seat
- 6 Modes of Versatility: Offers multiple configurations, from infant car seat to stroller seat and even carriage mode.
- Comfort for Baby: Carriage mode lets your little one fully recline and stretch out during travel.
- Easy Installation: Features a Lite Max Infant Car Seat with a stay-in-car base and integrated belt lock-off system for secure, quick installation.
- Parent-Friendly Design: Includes an oversized storage basket, large cruiser tires, a parent cup holder, and a child snack tray.
- Self-Standing Fold: Convenient self-standing fold for easy storage and transport with trigger-fold activation.
- Built for Safety: An anti-rebound bar in the car seat limits movement in case of frontal impacts and meets rigorous safety standards.
- Long-Term Use: Stroller accommodates up to 50 lbs and is compatible with the Lite Max Infant Car Seat for babies 4-35 lbs.
Safety 1st Grow and Go All-in-One
- 3-in-1 Convertible Design: Easily transitions from rear-facing infant seat to forward-facing toddler seat and booster seat.
- Extended Use: Suitable for 5-100 lbs babies, providing long-term use as your child grows.
- Quick & Easy Installation: Features Quick Fit harness system, allowing you to adjust the harness without rethreading.
- Side Impact Protection: Equipped with multiple layers of side impact protection for extra safety.
- Machine-Washable Seat Pad: Convenient, easy-to-remove seat pad that is machine washable for hassle-free cleaning.
- Comfort for All Stages: The adjustable headrest and padded harness straps ensure a custom, comfy fit as your child grows.
- Compact & Space-Saving: Designed to fit three car seats across in most vehicles, making it an excellent option for families with multiple children.
Safety 1st Crosstown DLX All-in-One
- 3-in-1 Versatility: Converts from rear-facing to forward-facing and booster mode, supporting children from 5-100 lbs.
- Side Impact Protection: Features enhanced side impact protection to keep your little one safe in all situations.
- Quick Fit Harness System: Easily adjust the harness and headrest with a single hand; no rethreading is required.
- Comfy for All Stages: Plush padding and a 5-position harness to ensure a snug and comfortable fit as your child grows.
- Easy Installation: Installs quickly with the LATCH system and has clear, color-coded guides for a secure fit.
- Machine-Washable Seat Pad: Removable, machine-washable seat cover for easy cleaning after every spill.
- Space-Saving Design: Compact size fits most vehicles, allowing you to fit three seats for larger families.
RELATED: 10 Best Car Seat For Twins Reviews
Making the Right Choice: Which One Should You Choose?
Several key factors must be considered when choosing between an infant car seat vs an all-in-one car seat.
Baby’s Age and Size: Infant car seats are ideal for newborns and babies up to 12 months, offering a secure, snug fit. Once your child outgrows the seat, it’s time to transition to a larger option, like an all-in-one car seat, which grows with your child, lasting well into their toddler and booster seat years.
Lifestyle: If you’re always moving, an infant car seat may be better. Small, light, and portable, it fits into travel systems. For a long-term solution, an all-in-one car seat may be ideal since you won’t need to upgrade.
Car Size: Small cars may benefit from infant seats’ compact designs, while larger vehicles can accommodate the bulkier all-in-one models without taking up too much space.
Real-Life Scenarios: Consider your daily routine. Parents who drive long distances or have multiple children may enjoy an all-in-one car seat because it’s versatile and durable. For city parents or those who need a car seat for short journeys, an infant seat may be more portable.
Our Recommendation
An Infant car seat is the safest, easiest, and most portable way for families who care about safety to travel with a newborn. An all in one car seat, on the other hand, is the best choice if you want a cheap option that will last and cover all stages. Still not sure? Visit a store near you that sells baby gear and try both types in your car. Every family has different needs, and the best car seat for you is the one that works best with your lifestyle.
Conclusion
Finally, your family’s needs will determine whether you should choose an Infant car seat or an all in one car seat. Infant car seats are great for babies because they are small and easy to use, especially when traveling. They are limited in use and require an upgrade once your baby outgrows it.
On the other hand, all-in-one car seats provide long-term value by growing with your child from rear-facing to forward-facing and eventually as a booster seat. While bulkier and less portable, they save money in the long run.
Ultimately, the choice depends on your lifestyle and whether you prefer a convenient, short-term solution or a versatile, long-lasting investment. Both options prioritize your baby’s safety and comfort regardless of your choice. Weigh the pros and cons to determine the best option for your family, considering the infant car seat vs all in one decision.
FAQs About infant car seat vs all in one
Infant car seats are typically used for newborns up to 12 months or when the weight limit is exceeded.
Many all-in-one car seats offer rear-facing settings suitable for newborns, with adjustable harness systems.
No, extended time in an infant seat can cause breathing issues. Limit time to 2 hours at a stretch.
The best newborn car seat offers a snug, rear-facing design with proper support and side-impact protection for safety.
Infant car seats are designed for newborns with specific support, while regular seats are for older children.
Yes, most infant car seats are FAA-approved for airplane use, ensuring your baby’s safety during flights.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc, or its affiliates.
Leave a Reply