As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Choosing the correct pacifier for your baby can feel like navigating a sea of options, but the decision often comes down to one important choice: rubber vs silicone pacifier.
Both materials have been popular for years, offering unique benefits and drawbacks. People like rubber pacifiers because they are soft and feel natural, while people like silicone pacifiers because they last a long time and are easy to clean.
If you want to make the best choice for your child, read this post. It will explain the main differences between these two products. Whether you’re a first-time parent or just looking to switch things up, understanding the pros and cons of each will ensure you make an informed decision.
What Are Rubber Pacifiers?
Most rubber pacifiers are made from natural latex rubber. As a result of their soft feel, which is similar to breast milk, they are often chosen for babies. These pacifiers are flexible and gentle on a baby’s delicate gums. Historically, rubber pacifiers were some of the first introduced to the market, and many generations of parents have used them.
However, while rubber pacifiers are generally durable, they have a distinct smell and may discolor or degrade over time. Parents should know that some babies may be allergic to rubber and should be aware of this.
What Are Silicone Pacifiers?
Silicone pacifiers are made from synthetic rubber, which is non-toxic, hypoallergenic, and heat-resistant. They offer a more neutral taste and odor, making them a popular choice for babies sensitive to the smell or taste of rubber. Silicone pacifiers are known for their durability and smooth texture, which makes them easy to clean.
They will also last longer than rubber pacifiers because they are more durable. Silicone doesn’t change colour or pick up smells like rubber does, so many parents choose it over rubber because it lasts longer.
Rubber vs Silicone Pacifier: Key Differences
Material Properties
- Rubber: Soft, flexible, and more like the texture of the breast, but can absorb smells and deteriorate faster.
- Silicone: Harder and more durable, with a smooth surface that is easy to clean and long-lasting.
Taste & Texture
- Rubber: Slightly softer, but has a noticeable taste and odor, which some babies might not like.
- Silicone: It has a more neutral taste and smell and a harder, smoother feel that some babies like.
Durability and Longevity
- Rubber: More prone to wear and tear, discoloration, and developing cracks.
Silicone: Better value in the long run because it is more sturdy and won’t break down as quickly.
Pros and Cons of Rubber Pacifiers
Pros:
- Soft & Flexible: Rubber pacifiers are gentle on baby’s gums, making them ideal for newborns and younger infants.
- Mimics Breast: The natural rubber texture closely mimics the breast, which can be comforting for breastfeeding babies.
Cons:
- Latex Allergies: Some babies may develop a rash or allergic reaction to latex, making them unsuitable for all children.
- Odor & Discoloration: Rubber can take in smells and change colour over time, which makes it less appealing.
Pros and Cons of Silicone Pacifiers
Pros:
- Hypoallergenic: Silicone is a non-toxic material that is gentle on sensitive skin and is a safer choice for babies with allergies.
- Easy to Clean: Silicone pacifiers are resistant to bacteria and can be sterilized without worry. Their smooth texture also prevents them from retaining odors.
- Durability: They are more durable than rubber pacifiers and last longer, making them a better investment in the long run.
Cons:
- Stiffness: Silicone pacifiers can be stiffer, which might not be as comforting for babies who prefer the softer feel of rubber.
Price: Silicone pacifiers tend to be more expensive than rubber ones.
Rubber vs Silicone Pacifier Comparison In 2025
Image | Product | Detail | Price |
---|---|---|---|
![]() | BIBS Pacifiers |
| Price |
![]() | NUK Comfy Orthodontic Pacifiers |
| Price |
![]() | MAM Original Pure Pacifier |
| Price |
![]() | Tommee Tippee Ultra-Light Silicone Pacifier |
| Price |
![]() | Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier |
| Price |
![]() | Itzy Ritzy Natural Rubber Pacifiers |
| Price |
Natural Rubber Baby Pacifier

- Natural Rubber Latex: Soft, safe, and durable for your baby’s comfort.
- BPA-Free: Made with food-grade, non-toxic materials.
- Gentle Shield Design: Minimizes contact with the baby’s delicate skin.
- Classic, Timeless Look: Available in beautiful, modern colors like Sage/Ivory.
If you’re a parent, you know that finding the correct pacifier for your baby is essential. It’s not just about comfort—it’s about safety, durability, and a design that works for you and your little one.
Enter the BIBS Natural Rubber Baby Pacifier. Made with soft, natural rubber and designed in Denmark, this pacifier has been a favorite of moms and babies for over 40 years. Because of its classic style and well-thought-out construction, your baby will be able to calm down in the most natural way possible.
The nipple shape is designed to be comfortable for babies, and the material is free of BPA. This pacifier was made with care and quality in mind.
Pros
- Stylish and Functional
- It’s BPA-free
- Easy to Clean and Durable
- The Natural Rubber Material Feels Soft and Soothing
Cons
- The Nipple Gets Sticky
NUK Comfy Orthodontic Pacifiers

- Orthodontic Nipple Design: Promotes healthy oral development.
- Breast-like Nipple Shape: Fits baby’s palate for easy transitions.
- 100% Medical-Grade Silicone: Soft, safe, and easy to clean.
- Heart-Shaped Shield: Prevents irritation and supports breathing.
- Made in the USA: Crafted with care and trusted by parents.
Finding a safe, comfortable, and supportive pacifier for your baby’s development can feel overwhelming. Thankfully, the NUK Comfy Orthodontic Pacifier combines over 60 years of trusted pediatric expertise with thoughtful design to create the ideal solution for your little one.
From its one-piece medical-grade silicone construction to the unique heart-shaped shield, this pacifier offers more than just comfort—it supports healthy oral development and seamless transitions from breast to pacifier. It’s no wonder parents everywhere trust NUK. Are you curious to know what makes the NUK Comfy stand out?
Pros
- Perfect Size
- Breast-like Nipple Shape
- Durable And Easy to Clean
- The Colors are a Nice Touch
Cons
- Pacifiers Seem to be Little Shorter
MAM Original Pure Pacifier

- Eco-Friendly Materials: Made from sustainable bio-renewable sources.
- Soft Silicone Nipple: Designed to mimic the natural feel of mom’s breast.
- Unique Sterilizing Box: Makes cleaning simple and efficient.
- BPA-Free and BPS-Free: Ensures safe, non-toxic use.
- Orthodontic Design: Supports healthy oral development.
- Premium Quality: Built to last while maintaining baby’s comfort.
When it comes to pacifiers, finding an eco-friendly option that’s gentle on your baby and the planet can seem like an uphill task. Enter the MAM Original Pure Pacifiers. Made with sustainable bio-renewable materials, these pacifiers don’t just soothe—they help support a greener world. With a soft, breast-like nipple design and a convenient sterilizing box, these pacifiers blend functionality, comfort, and sustainability. Are you curious about what sets these pacifiers apart from the rest?
Pros
- It’s Natural Rubber and Eco Friendly Materials
- Hold up Really Well and Have Neutral color Options
- Easy To Clean
Cons
- Extra Expensive
Tommee Tippee Ultra-Light Silicone Pacifier

- Feather-Light Design: Stays put without feeling heavy.
- Ultra-Soft Silicone: Gentle on sensitive gums and teeth.
- One-Piece Construction: Easy to clean and maintain.
- BPA-Free: Safe and non-toxic for peace of mind.
- Symmetrical Nipple Shape: Supports natural oral development.
- Trusted Brand: Designed with parent and baby in mind.
For parents who want a pacifier that’s as gentle as it is lightweight, the Tommee Tippee Ultra-Light Silicone Pacifier stands out. Its feather-light design ensures your baby can comfortably keep it in their mouth without feeling weighed down, while the ultra-soft silicone provides a soothing, natural feel.
This pacifier combines thoughtful engineering with a baby-friendly design, making it a trusted choice for keeping your little one calm and happy. Are you curious to know why parents rave about this pacifier?
Pros
- Super Lightweight
- The Pacifier is a Little Rounded to Keep The Pacifier in
- Size is Perfect For Any Baby Under 1
- It’s Super Cute, Durable, and Easy to Clean
Cons
- The pacifiers need to get bigger as babies get bigger
Philips Avent Soothie Pacifiers

- Trusted by medical professionals: Widely used in hospitals to soothe newborns.
- Orthodontic design: Symmetrical nipple supports proper oral development.
- 100% medical-grade silicone: Safe, flexible, and durable.
- Finger-held design: Strengthens the bond between parent and baby.
- BPA & latex-free: Safe for your baby’s delicate health.
- Easy to clean: Sterilize or boil for convenience.
When it comes to your newborn’s comfort, choosing the correct pacifier is crucial. The Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier, designed for babies aged 0-3 months, offers the perfect blend of safety, comfort, and oral health benefits. Trusted by hospitals and recommended by pediatricians, this pacifier is made from 100% medical-grade silicone, ensuring it’s gentle on your baby’s sensitive gums. Whether it’s calming your baby during nap time or supporting natural oral development, the Avent Soothie is a reliable choice for parents.
Pros
- They’re Effective, Soothing and Durable
- Lightweight, and Easy for Babies to Suck
- It is Easier For Baby To Transition
- Super Cute for a Subtle Design
Cons
- These are fully circular and smell like rubber
Itzy Ritzy Natural Rubber Pacifiers

- 100% Natural Rubber: Soft, safe, and durable.
- Ergonomic Shield Design: Reduces contact with baby’s sensitive skin.
- Stylish Colors: Matches modern baby gear and clothing.
- BPA-Free: Safe and non-toxic for peace of mind.
- Easy to Clean: Simple, quick sterilization for busy parents.
- Trusted Brand: Known for high-quality, trendy baby products.
For new parents, finding a pacifier that’s not only safe but also soothing and stylish can be a real challenge. The Itzy Ritzy Natural Rubber Pacifiers make the choice easier by combining high-quality materials, an innovative design, and trendy aesthetics.
These pacifiers help keep your baby calm and happy while providing peace of mind for you. Whether you’re drawn to their natural rubber composition or the chic colors that coordinate with your baby’s outfits, Itzy Ritzy pacifiers have something for every family. Ready to see why they’ve become a must-have for modern parents?
Pros
- Very Secure To The Plastic Piece
- Cute, nice colors and perfect size
- It’s lightweight, Great Quality, and Durable
- Easy to clean
Cons
- Water Seems to Get Trapped in the Nipple
Which Material is Better for Your Baby?
The choice between rubber and silicone pacifiers depends on a few factors, including your baby’s age, needs, and preferences:
- Rubber Pacifiers are ideal for younger infants or babies who prefer a softer, more flexible feel.
- Silicone Pacifiers are a great option for babies with sensitive skin or allergies, and they are generally more durable and longer-lasting.
Silicone may be the safer choice if your baby is prone to allergies or skin irritation. However, rubber might be more appealing if your baby prefers a softer texture. The finest pacifier for your baby satisfies their demands while being safe and comfortable.
Conclusion on Rubber vs Silicone Pacifier
It depends on your baby’s comfort and your own needs as a parent which pacifier to choose between rubber vs silicone pacifier. Silicone pacifiers last longer, are hypoallergenic, and are easy to clean than rubber pacifiers. Rubber pacifiers are softer and more bendable. When it comes to your baby’s wants, the best material will depend on the pros and cons of each.
Ultimately, the choice between rubber vs silicone pacifier comes down to personal preference and your baby’s specific needs. Silicone pacifiers are a great choice for those seeking a safe, durable, and hygienic solution.
FAQs About Rubber vs Silicone Pacifier
Silicone is better for pacifiers because it lasts longer, is easier to clean, and doesn’t stain or smell.
Silicone is hypoallergenic and less likely to irritate sensitive skin than rubber, making it a safer choice for most babies.
You should get a new pacifier every one to two months, or sooner if they start to crack or change colour.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc, or its affiliates.
Leave a Reply